THE Chinese blogosphere has moved on very quickly from the case of Chen Guangcheng. (The blind activist arrived in America on May 19th, more than four weeks after he first took refuge in the American embassy). Mr Chen's case has not disappeared from view entirely. Instead the accusations about the Americans scheming to assist Mr Chen in his escape from house arrest have been folded into a broader debate about foreigners in China.
Ever since foreigners arrived in China in large numbers in the 19th century, there has been a tendency either to lionise all that is foreign or to denigrate it, and to treat foreigners themselves either as gods or as barbarians. That dynamic has been very much on display in recent weeks.
First, in the divine department, in early May a young language student from America saw an old beggar, bought her some chips and sat down to have a chat with her. Someone snapped a picture, put it on the internet and soon the young man was regarded as a full-blown hero. Cue the soul-searching among Chinese bloggers, wondering helplessly why the Chinese people cannot be more like this foreigner.
Around the same time, a good Samaritan from Brazil came to the rescue of a Chinese woman who was being mugged. He was beaten up himself while a Chinese crowd stood watching. This came only months after a Uruguayan woman had saved someone from drowning in Hangzhou's West lake. Both cases stirred up similar hand-wringing about China losing its moral compass, and needing to learn more from foreigners and so on. (One of the reasons the now-purged boss of Chongqing, Bo Xilai, was so popular was for espousing a return to good old-fashioned Maoist morality, a sort of “back to basics” movement for 21st century China.)
Then, just as the nearly 1m foreigners living in China could bear the adulation no longer, along came a lout from Britain to play the barbarian card (pictured above). On May 8th a video was posted on YouKu (and soon after on its foreign equivalent, YouTube) showing a Western man apparently trying to sexually assault a Chinese woman beside a busy street in central Beijing. In the extraordinary footage various Chinese people try to intervene, at least up to the point when the (clearly inebriated) man then passed out in the middle of the road. The anger with which he was being kicked by one Chinese passerby seems to hint at the sense of grievance that has been building up towards foreigners in recent months (or centuries). The same Brit had, it turned out, been spotted (and photographed) sexually harassing young women on the Beijing underground; and photos of that were posted on Sina Weibo. While politically sensitive words, photos and videos are erased from Chinese websites almost immediately, non-political posts such as these are still allowed—even when they are inflammatory. (A few English-language websites make it easy to catch a glimpse of what circulates on the Chinese web.
At almost the same time another video of a Western man behaving badly came to light, this one on a train journey from Shenyang to Beijing. A foul-mouthed Russian puts his feet up on the back of a Chinese woman's seat and proceeds to spew forth a torrent of abuse in Mandarin when she objects. When the train's conductor arrives and sheepishly asks what's going on (kid gloves for barbarians), the dissolute white man foolishly boasts that he is a cellist. That was enough for the online mob to track him down and discover that he is the principal cellist in the Beijing Symphony Orchestra, a Russian called Oleg Vedernikov. He apologised for his behaviour but was subsequently suspended from the orchestra. All of this has played out against a new campaign to crack down on foreigners living in China illegally. Some Chinese bloggers have praised it as a move to kick out “foreign trash”.
But such posturing was as nothing compared to the online tirade that was launched by one of the most visible presenters on China Central Television (CCTV), Yang Rui. Mr Yang is well known as the host of “Dialogue”, a programme on CCTV's main English-language channel in which foreigners are invited to discuss issues of the day. On May 16th Mr Yang used his microblog to trumpet his full support of the new campaign against illegal foreigners, saying that the public-security ministry “must clean out the foreign trash, catch foreign lowlifes and protect innocent girls”. He also urged Chinese people to “learn to recognise the foreign spies who find a Chinese girl to shack up with while they make a living compiling intelligence reports”. He then called the expelled Al Jazeera correspondent Melissa Chan “a bitch” and said that anyone who demonises China should shut up and get lost (to paraphrase politely).
It should be pointed out that most Chinese people are extremely courteous and hospitable to foreigners who come to China. But recent diplomatic spats have bred tensions. The rant may or may not seem extreme if it were coming from your average Zhou—indeed commercial American TV plays host to some pretty xenophobic rants as well—but coming as it does from the highest-profile English-language host on CCTV, it has caused some consternation. Certainly there are plenty of young foreigners drifting through China, as there are in many Asian countries, and they sometimes cause annoyance or worse. But for a leading public figure to act out such xenophobia is a shock. Subsequent messages on Mr Yang's microblog have included barbs for the Philippines and Vietnam over their policies in the South China Sea. One of these ends with the phrase “don't try to mess with us or it'll be no more Mr Nice Guy”.
Three things are noteworthy about the fallout from Mr Yang's rants. First, the extent to which other Chinese microbloggers have pushed back at his apparent xenophobia. The two decades after the Tiananmen Square uprising in 1989 were broadly characterised by growing anti-foreign sentiment. Young Chinese were enjoying their country's increased international influence and starting to see the West, and especially America, as an international bully. (Does anyone in the West even remember NATO's bombing of the Chinese embassy in Belgrade in 1999? Everyone in China does.) In the past couple of years however, debate has become more nuanced as a growing number of younger, increasingly urbanised Chinese people start to distinguish between their opinion of the Communist Party from their pride in their nation. This is a generation that sees Chinese patriotism as being compatible with criticism of the government's policies. (Something that Westerners have yet to master—eg, in the run-up to America's invasion of Iraq, when anti-war protesters were routinely lambasted as “unpatriotic”.) This marks a huge change for China. The dialogue provoked by Mr Yang's comments has contributed to a debate that is fundamentally enlightening, albeit sometimes overheated and nationalistic.
The second point is perhaps farther-reaching, and more worrying. Certainly there is plenty of opposition to the rants of Yang Rui and others like him, but there is also a great deal of support. The fear is that this will grow. On nationalistic issues the general public can become more militant than the government—indeed it often accuses the government of being too soft. At the same time that China is becoming more confident internationally, after 30 years of scorched-earth GDP growth, the Chinese economy is starting to slow. Lower rates of growth seem sure to accentuate brooding social problems. Complaints at home, in turn, might tempt the Chinese government to channel popular anger towards that old bugbear, “outside forces”, to vent these frustrations. In recent years they have been particularly adept at using Japan to this end, but America is another favourite target. The fact that Yang Rui felt that he, a high-profile TV host, could raise such incendiary topics says much about the prevailing mood in official circles in Beijing.
The third issue highlighted by Mr Yang and his detractors is the huge role that the internet—and especially microblogs—are playing in Chinese discourse, and ultimately in government policy. The Chinese-language internet has already had a crucial effect in creating a more sophisticated, informed and critical public awareness. But it can easily inflame nationalistic tempers too. Because the government's censors are still able to set some limits to web traffic, they retain remarkable power to manipulate popular feeling, for better and for worse.
Bearing in mind the sensitive atmosphere of the moment, perhaps it is amazing that there hasn't been more online anger—for or against Bo Xilai and the princelings, for instance. Or that Chen Guangcheng's departure for America went as smoothly as it did. What is clear is that underneath that smooth, calm surface, people are seething. As if there were not enough for microbloggers to gripe about, the new anti-foreigner spirit adds a dangerous element to the mix. Even Mr Yang himself seemed to recognise this, in a later blog post, when he said that, while it is “important to sweep away all the foreign trash”, Chinese people must “also be cautious of xenophobia and new variations on the Boxer Uprising”. Meanwhile, young Westerners in Chinese cities are urgently making sure their papers are in order.



Readers' comments
The Economist welcomes your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful of other readers. Review our comments policy.
Sort:
For example during the 2008 Beijing Olympics the CCCP 'forgaave' the "slit eyed" photos done by some Western teams ( while the rest of the population were fuming). this shows the servility of the CCCP to White Western Nations.
oh come on bro. In China if you're white you are God. If you are non white you are barbarian- in various degrees. That Brazilian must have ben mullato.
2) White men are seen as takers of Chinese women. That's why that visceral response.
Are you naïve or plain blind in mind?
The problem is that too many scumbags from the western world move to China for so-called teaching. but what they actually after is sexual adventures. I have been to China about 5 times on business trips and each time I come across many foreigners specailly western countries that they brag about their sexual adventures and they wont be a shamed of having sex with girls as young as their doughters.
the problem is, my Chinese friend, your women throw themselves at the white men
What is this bloody egit doing writing about China. The author of this article clearly has not gained any real experience in how the party, the people and this country operate both domestically and abroad. Videos like the one cited here have been going up on youku since the site's inception. The reality is there are just some bad people out there. The fact attention, and Rui have been allowed to proceed in the way they have is merely a reflection of party will, seen one of the rare accurate statements in this article. Growth is slowing and the party need a vent.
I would suggest awonderful dichotomy of literature: John and Doris Naisbitt's China's Megatrends, and Guy Sorman's The Empire of Lies.
Have a read of those and then go travel (without chaperones) around China.
The Chinese foreigners law which will be published next year in 2013 that will restrict foreign expats and visitors. you must provide your bills and payment statement for recent 12 months, your income payslips, housing license, etc.
establishing a organization which will investigated the diploma or certificate that you are holding, (e.g. if you are saying that you are graduated from University of Chicago, the org will contact the university to verify your identity and your diploma)
sex tourists, if you get caught, 1000 dollars fine, 15 days in prison, and your name is in their system, you might be not welcomed to China next time.
Various medias in China claimed that Chinese people should never over-welcome foreigners from now on; that century has gone forever.
foreign cheaters are every where in China, pretending to be some executives, joining ceremony, who are pieces of shit in america.
the last thing you gotta know, the Chinese girls when you were thinking whom were very easy to get laid, you must be wrong. the majority are not open to foreigners, like Japanese.
You might be proud that you had sex with more than 10 or 20 girls, most likely, Girls at bars or clubs in wanting of foreigners to take them to developed countries (coz they are poor, might be from villages), some are sluts,(they don't think that you fucked them, but they think that they've fucked you, played some foreigners, counting how many nationalities they have slept with; they might be the HIV carrier, and be aware of that virus could be underneath in 7 years without notice till one day that you have to farewell with your penis; of course they are some really good girls, meet you in the right time, right place or you may have a wonderful marriage with her in your entire life, congrats then)
I am from Zurich, I had live in Beijing, Shanghai and Dalian for 10 years, I knew things in China even better than in Zurich. Trust me or not, up to you.
By the way, why everything good in China after being written by some unknown authors from the Economists tend to be all of shitty prejudice?
Please, Write something for your bloody English Empire. still dreaming there, huh? Fucking weak currency, increase tuition fee for your students, not daring to do the torch relay around the world because of the Bloody UK fear of many countries will stop that shit relay. TE, write something for your own country, apologize to the victims when you were done to them, like how German repay to the Jews. write something to your government, you have to return the treasure you have stolen that listed in your museum. write something to your government, why the spring riots happened, why you people burnt the stores, stole the goods, fight on the streets. that's what a media should do for its country instead of making propaganda for other countries.
ABC, NHK, TIMES, Bloomberg's business week, or any other state medias from Switzerland, Finland, Canada, Japan and Norway are way way way more neutral and subjective than THE ECONOMIST.
"A Mexican blogger and former journalist who is studying Mandarin in Taiwan recently blogged about his life, highlighted by the New Year celebration."
"He said they bumped into several policemen in the park, which immediately made him think of the police back home, who would be likely to shake them down."
"In the most kind manner, they told us we don’t have to drink in a park, but if we want, we can find a table outside some bar or, more directly, somewhere with more light,” he wrote."
"The police officers’ friendliness surprised him and left him moved."
"Seeing Taiwan’s stability and progress, Felix said that he wished the social order in his country could one day be as comforting as here."
http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiwan/archives/2012/01/10/2003522884
Taiwan, the Jewel of Asia, on its way to become Asia's Switzerland.
I would really like the Economist Magazine focus on the Economy rather than Political or Cultural reporting, because the Economist is far from professional on other matters, and the writers have extremely not neutral attitude towards other countries.
So please, close your Politics category, Times Magazine are way better than yours.
The future China is afraid of.
http://www.harrycutting.com/graphics/photos/families/chinese-white-famil...
Umm too late.
Firstly,the fact that the "western man" who sexually assaulted a Chinese girl is actually an English man was not mentioned in the article. Secondly,it is taken for granted that the sexual assault should always be condemned and denounced. Not providing the ins and outs of the matter but extremely depicting the reasonable and seasonable succour from a passer-by as a "Barbarians" behaviour is in danger of sophistry and cover-up. Last but not least,as a Chinese saying goes "Do not do to others what you would not have them do to you", when traveling abroad, to respect the local custom and obey the local regulation is a basic common knowledge.
Taiwan welcomes foreigners as brothers.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEuRqOAOuhw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QTZlOci8DMs
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FojL1cw-y20
China views foreigners as suspects, spies, etc.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XDDeLBBR7UM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKXBQT5yI0s
If you treat someone roughly, do you expect love in return?
@TW ISLAND NATION,
It seems non-Chinese has strong complex problem too as reflected by your comments, denigrating Chinese recklessly is a sign of inferior complex when they face a rising China. Japanese has a lot of undesirable traits that can be laughed at, but it would become racist if they are revealed here if I stoop as low as you.
This 9 year old kid who owns 103483 different TE accounts is confusing anecdotal evidence with general trends again.
There's a lot of unfair remarks here made against Chinese women from the mainland, one of whom was the assault victim of this rogue foreigner. What is left out of this increasingly disgusting conversation on TE forum is the alluring factors of these Chinese girls.
Most Chinese girls are cute, dimunitive and very smart. But that's not what attracts them to many foreigner males. It's their PRC citizenship and therefore their ability to help confer the much covetted PRC green card or resident status to their future spouses.
Many foreigners, men in particular, including rthe pompous writers at the Shanghaiist.com, owe their resident status to their marriage to such local women. ingrates!!
Many US grads of 2011 are still unemployed. Recently I saw on TV the plight of a Princeton alumni who is struggling to find a good job. His solution: learn Mandarin and apply for a position in China. He said that a two or three year stint in China will help him get a better job here in America when he returns.
In the meantime, throngs of unemployed grads are also heading overseas for greener pastures.
www.CNBC.com/id/45567659
"Mssive Americans go abroad for economic opportunites"
"There's a lot of unfair remarks here made against Chinese women from the mainland"
As an ethnic Chinese, I agree with your sentiment. There's just way too much abuse against the Chinese, both men and women, in Western media. It's very unfair and extremely hurtfull to everyone of us Chinese when one or a group of us are unjustifiably insulted like this. It's like being kicked in the gut.
One of the most disgusting insults contained in Bismarck's vicious link was the remark about Wendy Deng Murdoch, portraying her as vixen and opportunist. Nothing is farthest from the truth. Wendy Deng is extremely smart and graduated from Yale business school, something that neither Murdoch or any of his sons can claim. Before coming to US, Wendy had studied medicine in China. No slouch to begin with, don't you think.
If there's an opportunist here, it's Murdoch himself. A decade ago he complained loudly to Zhu Rongzi that his broadcasting corp can't seem to get the proper license to operate in China. Jokingly or maybe not jokingly, Zhu Rongsi told him to marry a Chinese woman, a citizen of the Peoples' Republic of China. Eventually, he went on to marry Wendy, a Chinese citizen. Unfortunately, we won't know whether he's exploiting her or not until the two love birds publish their memoirs. They seem to be meant for each other.
This unkind remark about a brilliant woman is another manifest of racism againt successful Chinese people. When Suzanne 'Suzy' Wetlaufer slept with Jack Welch, and succeeded to home wreck his marriage to Jane Beasley, nobody in the press called her a gold digger or some greedy bitch! If fact they praise her for writing the book with Jack Welch. Double Standard, don't you think!!!
"There's a lot of unfair remarks here made against Chinese women from the mainland"
As an ethnic Chinese, I agree with your sentiment. There's just way too much abuse against the Chinese, both men and women, in Western media. It's very unfair and extremely hurtfull to everyone of us Chinese when one or a group of us are unjustifiably insulted like this. It's like being kicked in the gut.
One of the most disgusting insults contained in Bismarck's vicious link was the remark about Wendy Deng Murdoch, portraying her as vixen and opportunist. Nothing is farthest from the truth. Wendy Deng is extremely smart and graduated from Yale business school, something that neither Murdoch or any of his sons can claim. Before coming to US, Wendy had studied medicine in China. No slouch to begin with, don't you think.
If there's an opportunist here, it's Murdoch himself. A decade ago he complained loudly to Zhu Rongzi that his broadcasting corp can't seem to get the proper license to operate in China. Jokingly or maybe not jokingly, Zhu Rongsi told him to marry a Chinese woman, a citizen of the Peoples' Republic of China. Eventually, he went on to marry Wendy, a Chinese citizen. Unfortunately, we won't know whether he's exploiting her or not until the two love birds publish their memoirs. They seem to be meant for each other.
This unkind remark about a brilliant woman is another manifest of racism againt successful Chinese people. When Suzanne 'Suzy' Wetlaufer slept with Jack Welch, and succeeded to home wreck his marriage to Jane Beasley, nobody in the press called her a gold digger or some greedy bitch! If fact they praise her for writing the book with Jack Welch. Double Standard, don't you think!!!
..
Blogger Mr. "Bismarck888" hates Chinese
Blogger Bismarck being Indian ---envy fair-skin Wendy Murdock
//
....
Asian countries are poor in reforming for the education, the only thing is a vision to make it possible...
I personally know quite a number of young British and Americans "drifting" in China. They are mostly English teachers in language schools, training centers, and kindergartens. They bought their fake teaching certificates before or after they came to China. Some even with their college degree papers fabricated.
They live in the country they hate. They make friends with the people they despise. They say this is a lawless country while they themselves are illegal.
immigrants will always be seen as a nuisance to the natives, no matter which country we are speaking about. it is simply human nature.
We really dislike and ready to beat up two sorts of foreigners: THE AUTHOR of this kind of prejudiced article and misbehaving trash living a lowlife in China. They both are trying to stain the greatest country with their tainted mind.
Yeah well the Chinese might have heard some of the hysterical ranting going on in the West about "foreigners".
We are hardly in a position to give lectures.
In my own travels to China, I have enjoyed the place immensely. Particularly Shanghai, which is one of these places with a large western population.
Bank Exchange Rate Blog
Here is something the Economist do not want us to know: google David Sassoon and Opium War. You'll know who instigated the war against China. And until now, they are still attacking us. Do not buy an Vidal Sassoon products. He was a descendant of David Sassoon.
I could not help but notice that Latin Americans in China behave quite well, I hope Chinese notice the difference between us and the rest.
we Chinese do not have intention of insulting any foreigners except those "criminal foreigners". we welcome people across the world to come to China to enjoy their life. it's not a bias to a certain people. so your worry is unnecessary.
Are you naive? A number of robbery cases happened in HK were done by Latin American.
Pablo said he noticed Latin Americans in China behave quite well. He did not say he noticed Latin Americans in Hong Kong behave quite well. Yes yes I know HK is a territory of China. But usually when someone says "China" they mean mainland China, not greater China. Just like when someone says USA they are usually talking about the 50 states, not Guam or Puerto Rico or other territories.
Not all foreigners in China are "young Westerners" Brown person from a developing country in Beijing right here, also getting my papers together.
And while I've never faced any overt hostility here, and many people have been very friendly and helpful, I don't think any dark-skinned foreigner in China gets the "gods" treatment.